3.08.2012

The Mechanism for Down, Edwards and Patau Syndromes

As a prelude to the next posting, here is a short summary of the mechanisms by which genetic conditions such as Down (trisomy 21) , Edwards (trisomy 18) and Patau (trisomy 13) syndromes can occur. Trisomy refers to the presence of an extra copy of a chromosome beyond the normal pair. Affected individuals may have 47 instead of 46 chromosomes, or may have 46 chromosomes, with one containing duplicate portions of a third.
Each human cell normally has a compliment of 46 chromosomes in 23 pairs. One copy in each pair is from the father and one from the mother. Every time a cell divides (mitosis) duplicates of each are made and this relationship is preserved. Absent mutation (or rare chimeric individuals) , every cell in your body contains the same genetic compliment.

The exception to this, of course is the process by which sex cells (gametes - eggs and sperm) are created for sexual reproduction in the process called meiosis.

Unlike mitosis, meiosis only occurs in testes or ovaries and has two distinct phases that result in daughter cells that differ greatly genetically from the parent cell..

In phase one of meiosis, each chromosome is duplicated prior to the first cellular division. Once duplicated, the chromosome pairs are in close proximity and a critical process occurs that will increase the diversity of chromosomes created by the process. This is called recombination or crossover.
Portions of one arm of a duplicate chromatid overlap, or crossover, with the arm of one of the complementary strands and they switch places. The result will ultimately be a unique chromosome made up of portions from the father's and mother's originals. Since this happens independently in every new gamete produced, the variability is great and the genetic diversity of the offspring will increase.
Phase one of meiosis ends when the cells divide into two cells each with one of the recombinant pairs of chromosomes.

In phase 2 of meiosis, the cells divide a second time and each gamete (egg or sperm) contains a single recombinant copy of each chromosome pair, i.e. 23 chromosomes instead of the typical 46. Because of crossover recombination during phase 1, the individual gametes will differ from each other and from the original copies inherited from this individual's parents.
Later, during reproduction one of these gametes will hopefully fuse with one from the partner creating a zygote that combines one copy of each chromosome from each parent returning the number of chromosomes to 46 in the new individual.

Unfortunately errors sometimes occur during this process. Often the errors create nonviable gametes but some combinations of errors may result in a viable pregnancy. One group of errors are the trisomy syndromes.

As you might imagine errors can occur in either the division of chromosome pairs or in the recombination process.
If the error is in the division of the chromosomes, one gamete of the 4 daughter cells will have an extra copy of a chromosome (24) and one will have none (22). The gamete absent a copy is usually nonviable with the exception of errors affecting the sex chromosomes. In some cases, a gamete having no copy of a y chromosome, can result in a viable zygote that has one X chromosome only (XO Turner syndrome). Gametes with full duplicate copies of a chromosome which create viable zygotes that go to term, will result in individuals with the most severe cases of the respective trisomy syndrome. The most common duplication errors that can go to term involve chromosomes 21, 18, and 13.

If the error is related to crossover recombination, there is a failure to compete a symmetrical transfer of genetic material from one chromatid to another. One will have duplicate DNA from the donor resulting in a hybrid chromosome.
Where and how much material is duplicated, will determine the severity of these incomplete trisomy cases which may present with less severe forms of the syndrome and have significantly different outcomes.

3.07.2012

Anatomy of an Un-apology

The Un-apology has become a staple of American politics. Caught red handed with one's hand in any metaphorical cookie jar and the right wing serial liar may be required to issue a formal un-apology. (Sometimes, they are sincerely sorry - that they got caught.)

GasBag issued one last week. Here is the transcript along with a literal translation:

A Statement from Rush: March 03, 2012
For over 20 years, I have illustrated the absurd with absurdity, (I am a hyperbolic ass) three hours a day, five days a week (apparently an unrecognized source of greenhouse gases. No wonder he's a climate change denier!) In this instance, I chose the wrong words in my analogy of the situation. I did not mean a personal attack on Ms. Fluke. (what is the correct word substitution for slut? MEANING: there was no way I could have imagined that calling a young woman a slut by name on national radio could be misinterpreted as a personal attack.)

[I think it is absolutely absurd that during these very serious political times, we are discussing personal sexual recreational activities before members of Congress. (yeah, we should be bad mouthing gays instead) I personally do not agree that American citizens should pay for these social activities. (Which is why Rush goes to Thailand for his) What happened to personal responsibility and accountability? (I don't know, people like you spit in its face, is my guess) Where do we draw the line? If this is accepted as the norm, what will follow? (If we accept sex as a natural part of life? Probably the downfall of the right is my guess) Will we be debating if taxpayers should pay for new sneakers for all students that are interested in running to keep fit? In my monologue, I posited that it is not our business whatsoever to know what is going on in anyone's bedroom (unless they are gay of course, then it's my business) nor do I think it is a topic that should reach a Presidential level.] Blah, blah, blah, yadda, yadda, yadda. Real intent of the message which is a staple of the un-apology which always contains a rationalization or excuse for the boorish or deceitful behavior. MEANING: over here! Pay no attention to what a misogynist gas bag I am, and ignore the fact that we already pay for Viagra. It's a guy thing, after all. My un-apology must restate my position, which is right and true. It helps later when I renounce my un-apology as just another attack by the liberal media devils. They tricked me in to being a total ass! Rush, it isn't hard to do. You ARE a total ass, this is just one time when people payed more attention.

My choice of words was not the best, (ya think?) and in the attempt to be humorous (trying to cloak a personal attack as misunderstood humor. If you call me on it, it means you have no sense of humor or are too sensitive. A classic bullying behavior.) , I created a national stir. I sincerely (oh, that makes it ok. That’s how we know it’s sincere - you said so! If you’d have left that out we might not have believed you) apologize to Ms. (Ms is code for feminazi) Fluke for the insulting word choices. (As opposed to the simple insulting tone and intent)

Gee, Rush, I guess we Un-accept...

3.06.2012

Three Blind Men and an Elephant...

Over at HuffPo, Rabbi Alan Lurie launches into a diatribe about atheists 'mental illness' and their lack of theological sophistication. Amind the rancor is the first reasonable (semi) and interesting theological argument I've heard in a long time. Unfortunately for him and his kind, it's an argument he can't use.

He's ripping on Richard Dawkin's well known comment about everyone being an atheist about all gods but their own. How true atheists differ from believers only by one god. The point is that with so many competing faiths why would anyone think that any one is correct - it's more logical to think that they are all false.

The rabbi talks about how this is a naive argument since the existence of competing faiths is illustrative of various cultures trying to come to grips with their perception of the existence of a greater power. I happen to agree.

Don't anyone get worried or rejoice. Perception is not fact. We perceive lots of things that aren't true. That's why so many of us depend upon the scientific method. It's the best way to counter perceptive bias we currently have. I agree that people perceive these things I just don't believe their perceptions are reflections of the true universe.

The perception part is key to me. I do believe that all these faiths are examples of people trying to make sense of the world. Each is colored by their cultural history. I agree with the rabbi that all believers are perceiving (or longing for) something greater than themselves, and like the old saw about the three blind men trying to describe an elephant, each falls short of a complete picture. Far from truly competing beliefs they are culturally biased expressions of some portion of the same thing.

It's an interesting and reasonable explanation for the presence of so many faiths. Unfortunately it's more use to a cultural anthropologist than a theologian. Because it suggests that no extant faith presents the full picture. Each is only a theory...

So it's not something that a theologian can use. But a deist, that's a different story.